Quarterback Greatness

Or Scopje, Macedonia.

 

Jim Brown was The Best.

But distinction noted.

 

Best is much more subjective than greatest.

 

Eli was more lucky than better ! lol.

 

True dat.

 

I never saw Jim Brown play, but can only imagine how great he was. to me - it's Barry Sanders and then everyone else behind him !

 

Bob Griese greater than Tom Brady?

 

No but he was like a greased pig.

 

To avoid you trotting out every QB, the QBs greater than Brady:
1 Joe Montana
2 Terry Bradshaw
3 Troy Aikman

 

but is Bob Griese greater than Brady?

 

Never losing in a SB is a trash metric of greatness.

 

Consult the list.

 

No because he lost to Dallas in the SB. But Eli Manning and Jim Plunkett are in the GOAT discussion because they won multiple SBs without losing one.

 

No, wrong. Greatness doesn't countenance failure on the biggest stage.

 

drink in the greatness.

 

honestly, im not trying to be a dick here. Id just like a clear response, are you claiming Bob Griese is greater than Tom Brady?

 

I don't even think anyone is truly arguing with you anymore because once you believe THAT then there is no point in going on. We are now just amusing each other.

 

it just fails earlier and has less success evidently.

 

That suit is NOT great. I feel like I need to tell him to be careful parking my car when I hand him the keys.

 

NOW you're getting it. Brady would be in the discussion for GOAT had he LOST in the AFC Title Game after the 2007, 2011, and 2017 seasons and never reached the SB those years.