Can't really mention Roethlisberger and Bell since the other poster is specifically talking about the starting and backup QB only
I don't think the question mark was because he didn't know who Schaub is...I think it is because he knows exactly who Schaub is...
BB agrees, apparently... "If you?re missing the quarterback, you can still get it and certainly we have a good quarterback in Jimmy, and Jimmy can go out and run everything that Tom can run. We?ve seen that. So I?m not saying that he?s not capable or qualified to do it. He is, and he does a great job of it. When we put Jimmy in there, it?s really seamless. Unless you were actually looking at the position, and if you just could just block out that position and say, ?Which guy was in there at quarterback?? I don?t know if you would know a lot of times." http://www.espn.com/blog/new-englan...has-high-praise-for-tom-brady-jimmy-garoppolo
But if Brady goes down, we can surmise based on the two games he did play that Garoppolo should play very well (and as noted BB seems pretty confident of that, as well). Whereas if Dak were to go down, we have no idea what level Romo will be at post-injury. So I'll take the guy who played excellently for two games over the guy who hasn't played at all. Brady > Prescott right now Garoppolo > Romo right now Emphasis on right now. Since the topic was the best 1-2 punch right now.
Actually, if we are comparing this year's work, as seems what you are doing with Romo vs. Garoppolo... Then, based on the Cowboys and Patriots team as a whole: Prescott 8-1>Brady 4-1 After all, I hear arguments on hear CONSTANTLY, the only thing that matters is wins...even when it comes to individual QBs
Well that's not what I was arguing, so whatever pops your corn. Dak's been great and all, but even his momma knows he ain't a better QB than Brady right now.
Yes. Garoppolo has played two games this season at a very high level. Romo hasn't played in a year. If/when he comes back and shows that he's still Romo, I'll revise my position.
To be fair, I misread the initial statement - I thought it said Dak and Zeke (talking about a 1-2 QB-RB punch). Yeah, Dak-Romo is the best. Schaub sucks.