David Carr's Top 10 QB's

Ok, call me a homer but this is beyond ridiculous ... his top 10 does not include Ben because his supporting cast does the bulk of the work ... honestly? Can any of you guys name another QB who has some good receivers? Where was Carr's sampling of Steeler wins with Ben but before AB or Bell ... People get paid for this crap? .... oh yeah no Carson Wentz either ... unimaginably stupid.

This, unfortunately is what we have to look forward to until camp... wonder how the badminton finals are going? ... maybe he corn toss quarter finals ...


http://www.steelersdepot.com/2018/0...top-10-qb-list-ranked-behind-jimmy-garoppolo/

 

Derek Carr at #4?

It's like the author is related to Derek or something, lol.

 

I know Ben can be a bonehead sometimes but a simple question I have is if u take Ben out and put in an average QB how effective would AB & Bell be?
My answer is not as good either.

Please advise

 

Here's the projected starters for 2018 -

Sam Bradford
Matt Ryan
Joe Flacco
Nathan Peterman
Cam Newton
Mitchell Trubisky
Andy Dalton
Tyrod Taylor
Dak Prescott
Case Keenum
Matthew Stafford
Aaron Rodgers
DeShaun Watson
Andrew Luck
Blake Bortles
Patrick Mahomes II
Philip Rivers
Jared Goff
Ryan Tannehill
Kirk Cousins
Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Eli Manning
Josh McCown
Derek Carr
Carson Wentz
Ben Roethlisberger
Jimmy Garoppolo
Russell Wilson
Jameis Winston
Marcus Mariota
Alex Smith

 

So, who wants to take a stab at the top 10?

 

Rogers
Brees
Brady
Roethlisberger
Ryan
Wilson
Wentz
Rivers
Stafford
Cousins

The rest suck

 

Ok, so my picks are predicated on two things ... first, who has impressed me in the past and who I think will impress me in the near future. I don't mean to snub some of the old timers here but I have a better feeling for a few of the younger guns than I do for sentimentality ...

Rogers
Brady
Brees
Ben
Ryan
Watson
Wentz
Stafford
Goff
Wilson

Luck would be there, if he was there, but hasn't been there, and I'm not yet convinced he will be there. But if he is, he'd be in my 10 spot.

 

rediiis
Mahomes and Garropalo are on the fence.

fricken fracken fence ! :-/ Hell, Garropalo has only taken toddler steps and Mahomes is in diapers and just been handed the keys to the car !

Check these guys out next year with same thread ... same with Mitch and Dak ... (hate the Boys but really am hoping Dak isn't a one hit wonder.)

 

@MaineofSteel

You have to learn how to quote people so they realize you quoted them.

 

Wow looking at these lists makes me realize the QBing in the NFL is poor after the top 5 IMHO.

I should clarify my point. There is a ton of projecting with QBs talents. There are very few established very good QBs.

 

Brady
Brees
Rodgers
Roethlisberger
Etc...............

It’s good to see David Carr hasn’t changed.

 

@MaineofSteel

You have to learn how to quote people so they realize you quoted them.

absolutely right Lym, how is it done so I can give credit where it is due ... where is the quote icon?

 

If this would have had teeth ... I was bit ... thanks anyway Lym, bringing it to my attention ...

 

You hit the reply button.

 

so I take it it's not copy and paste then insert in between [QUOTE QUOTE] ...

 

No the reply button does it for you.

 

No the reply button does it for you.

thanks Gid ...

 

only "reply" I saw was when I copied your sentence. just saw the reply button on far right ... I might be big and slow but I'm kinda dumb too

 

Maine, if you look to the right side of the post that you are reading, on the bottom of the post box you will see the word 'reply'.

Just click that and it will quote the post and label it so that the quoted poster gets an alert notifying them that you are responding to their post.