Quarterback Poll - AFC West

Discussion in 'NFL General Discussion' started by Lyman, Sep 21, 2020.

?

Who's the best?

Poll closed Sep 25, 2020.
  1. DEN - Drew Lock

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  2. K.C. - Pat Mahomes

    15 vote(s)
    100.0%
  3. L.V. - Derek Carr

    7 vote(s)
    46.7%
  4. LAC - Tyrod Taylor

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. Lyman "Franchise Asshole" Browns Buckeyes

    It looks like we're well into a "changing of the guard" when it comes to NFL Quarterbacks and I was wondering who you guys think is currently the best in the NFL. Stats and awards are nice can be (and often are) influenced by a QB's surrounding cast. I'm more interested in who you think is the best based solely on the "eye test".

    To that end, I'll create a series of polls - one for each Division.
    • The top two from each Divisional Round (8 QB's) will advance to their respective Conference Round.
    • The top three from each Conference Round (3 QB's) will advance to the Final Round.
    You get two votes in each Division.
     
    Last edited: Sep 21, 2020
  2. KilkennyDan Let's Go Buffalo! Patreon Champion Sabres Bills Kilkenny

    Are others not getting the idea? Or is it me?

    In the AFCW there is clearly one premier QB. It is also clear (to me) that the other three are not going to reach the Final Round. Still, 5 votes for Mahomes suggests that the sum of all remaining QB should be 5 too. But, it is 5-1. I voted for Carr and Mahomes; that indicates that four others voted for Mahomes and no other QB.

    Am I dense? Or does everyone need to be reminded to vote for 2 QB's in each division?

    BTW, thank you, Lyman, this should be fun and interesting.
     
    gidion72 likes this.
  3. gidion72 Legend Steelers

    I didn’t vote for two on the first two votes then I did on the other six
     
  4. Lyman "Franchise Asshole" Browns Buckeyes

    I should have stated, "you are allowed to vote for up to two" per Division.
     
    gidion72 likes this.
  5. gidion72 Legend Steelers

    Mahomes is the only QB worthy of voting for in the AFCW
     
  6. KilkennyDan Let's Go Buffalo! Patreon Champion Sabres Bills Kilkenny

    Thanks for the clarification. FWIW, I believe that the consistency and the integrity of results in the final voting, would be enhanced if EVERYONE votes for two QB's at the divisional round.
     
  7. Lyman "Franchise Asshole" Browns Buckeyes

    I agree. But I don't know how to ensure that happens. I may have to revise my criteria for advancing to the Conference Round (ie: top six vote getters regardless of Division).
     
  8. SoCalSaint Franchise Player Saints

    I didn't see that we could vote for more than one player. But I'll let my vote stand.
     

Share This Page